Parable

The Four Lines in Harrow’s Book

❯

Harrow kept the lock at Ebb Cross for thirty-one years, and when his knees gave out he left Ilse the keys, the cottage, and a book.

The book was thin and very old. Most of the pages were tide tables and the names of boats. The first page held his rules, and under the rules he had written: Read these every evening. If the lock breaks one, something is wrong.

For her first winter Ilse read them every evening, and the lock broke none of them. She liked that. It felt like Harrow was still standing at the wall with her, nodding.

By spring she had changed some things. The night barges had started coming up from the coast, and she hung a second lamp at the far end of the wall so they could see the gates before they hit them. Two dredgers had been scraping the stone every time they passed, so she turned them away, and she told the survey boats, who were careful but slow, to wait an extra hour so they didn't block the morning. The fish boat that came at dawn had started arriving early some days and late on others, so she let it through whenever it came, and if it went down and came back up again the same morning, she let it through twice.

One evening in April she read the rules and the lock broke four of them.

Nothing but the keeper's lamp on the wall.

Every boat waits its turn, and no boat waits longer than another.

The morning boat goes first, and once.

The count of boats in the book must match the count of boats on the water.


Her first feeling was that she had failed him. Her second feeling, close behind it, was that the rules were old and she knew better, and she reached for the pencil to cross them out.

She didn't, that night. She sat with the book open on the table and went down the list one at a time and asked each line a question: are you wrong, or am I?

The lamp was easy. She had hung it on purpose, for a reason Harrow never had, because in his time no boat moved after dark. The rule had been about not confusing the barges with stray lights. Her lamp was there to help them see. She wrote beside his line, small, in her own hand: Second lamp at the far gate, for the night barges. Nothing else.

The waiting was harder. Harrow had wanted fairness, and she had made some boats wait longer than others. But she knew which ones, and why: the dredgers broke the wall, and the slow boats blocked the river. She wrote that beside his line too, naming them, so that if a boat she hadn't named was ever made to wait, the rule would still catch it.

The morning boat took her a long time. It no longer always went first, and some days it went twice, and both of those were her choices. She rewrote the line so it would stop complaining about either. Then, before she closed the ink, she noticed what she'd done. The new line would let any boat pass twice in a morning, so long as it was the fish boat at least once. It would not notice a stranger slipping through on the fish boat's second turn.

She thought about tightening it and couldn't see how without breaking it again. So she left it as it was and wrote one more sentence underneath: This line is looser than it was. It will miss a boat that passes twice in the wrong place.


The count she almost crossed out without looking. The book said more boats than she could see on the water, every day, by a handful. It had been wrong for weeks, she realized, and she'd stopped noticing, the way you stop hearing a clock. It seemed obvious that the book was stale.

But this was the one rule where the old keeper and the river might genuinely disagree about something real, and if she crossed it out and the river was the one telling the truth, she would never hear it again. So she went down to the wall with the lantern and counted.

She counted the boats moored below the gate, and the boats above, and the ones tied up at the bank. Then she counted them against the book, name by name.

The difference was the lashed boats. Some of the families on the river had started tying two hulls together and sailing them as one, and the book still listed every hull. The water was right. A lashed pair went through the lock once and only needed counting once. When she counted what actually moved through the gates, the numbers matched to the boat.

She did not cross that line out either. She changed the word boats to passages, and in the margin she wrote which number she had checked against which, so whoever came after her could do it again.


It was late when she finished. Harrow's four lines were all still there, none of them struck through, each with a little column of her handwriting beside it. Every evening after that the lock broke none of them, and on the evenings it did, she went down to the wall first.

In the summer a boy from the village asked her why the first page of the book was in two different hands.

"That one's the keeper before me," she said. "That one's me, saying why the lock doesn't look the way he left it."

"Couldn't you just write new ones?"

She thought about the count, and the lantern, and how close she'd come.

"I could," she said. "Then I'd only have mine."

← Back to Writing