Parable

The Unlatched Gate

❯

Tobiah brought the bread to the Marrow farm every Tuesday and Friday for eleven years, and every time he stopped at the gate.

The gate had no lock. It had a latch you could lift with one finger. Still he stopped there, set the basket on the flat stone, and waited until somebody came out of the house and waved him up the path. Usually it was Orla, wiping her hands on her apron, calling from the step, "Come on, then. You know you don't have to wait."

He did know. She had told him in his second year, the winter his cart broke an axle in the ditch and she made him sit by her stove until his fingers worked again. "You're one of ours now," she'd said, pouring tea. "Walk straight up. Don't stand out there like a tax man."

He thanked her and meant it. On the next Tuesday he stopped at the gate.


In his fifth year Orla took a burnt stick from the stove and wrote on the gatepost, in letters a hand tall: TOBIAH WALK UP.

He read it every visit. He could have recited it in his sleep. He set the basket on the stone, read the post, and waited.

She came out and laughed at him. "It's written down now. What more do you need, a deed?"

"I read it," he said.

"And?"

He didn't have an answer that would sound right said out loud, so he said nothing, and she waved him up, and he went.


Her granddaughter was the one who asked properly. She was eight and had decided that grown-ups did most things for no reason, so she wanted the reason.

"Why do you wait? Gran says you're allowed."

Tobiah thought about it longer than she expected him to.

"When I stop here," he said, "somebody comes out."

"They'd be inside if you just went in. You'd see them anyway."

"That's true."

"So it's the same."

He didn't think it was the same, but he couldn't say how. He tried. "If I walk up, I'm somebody who belongs here. If I wait, I get told I belong here." He frowned at that. It sounded worse than he meant. "Every time," he added, which made it sound worse still.

The girl considered this with great seriousness. "So you like being told."

"I think I'm afraid that if I stopped needing it, nobody would bother saying it."

She went back into the house and told her grandmother all of it, word for word, the way children carry things they don't understand yet.


Orla didn't come out that Friday. Tobiah set the basket on the stone and waited. The words on the post had weathered grey but were still easy to read. The kitchen window was lit. He could see her shape moving behind it.

He waited a long time. Long enough to feel foolish, then long enough to feel something underneath the foolishness that he didn't have a name for. It was a little like hunger, and a little like the ditch with the broken axle.

Then the door opened, and she came down the path herself. She walked the whole way down, which she'd never done. She stood on the other side of the gate.

"I wanted to see if you'd come up on your own," she said.

"I didn't."

"No." She looked at the post, and then at him. "Child says you're afraid we'd stop saying it."

He looked at the basket.

"Tobiah. I wrote it on the wood. I said it eleven years. What did you think I was doing?"

"Saying it."

"I was trying to get it into you," she said. "That was the whole point. I wasn't trying to get it onto the post."


What she did next surprised them both. She didn't argue with him any further, and she didn't promise to keep coming out. She lifted the latch, swung the gate wide, and wedged the flat stone against the bottom of it so it couldn't close. Then she picked up the basket and carried it to the house herself, and left him standing at a gate that was open.

The next Tuesday the gate was still wedged. There was nowhere to stop. The stone he used to set the basket on was holding the gate open now.

He stood at the opening for a moment anyway, out of habit. Nobody came out.

Then he walked up the path, holding the bread, with nobody calling him, and with the old fear going the whole way beside him. It kept telling him he'd be unwelcome when he reached the door.

At the door it turned out he wasn't. Orla was at the table and didn't look up, only pushed the teapot an inch toward the empty chair, the way you do for someone who is already there.

He sat. It felt less like being welcomed than he was used to. It felt more like living there.

He wasn't sure, that first morning, that he liked it better. He missed her voice from the step. He told her so, eventually, years later, and she said she'd missed calling it.

They never put the latch back. Some mornings she still called to him from the step, on days she felt like it. Some mornings he still slowed at the opening before he remembered there was nothing there to stop at. Neither of them mentioned it.

← Back to Writing